Vicious Burchill
 


As Vicious As She Wants to Be

Julie Burchill has made a cottage industry out of attacking Martin Amis; this page offers highlights from her ongoing screed. 

bullet From the review of the play Julie Burchill is Away in the Financial Times, 11 June 2002 by Sarah Hemming: The play "is not so much a play as a collection of aphorisms, observations and opinions drawn from Burchill's writing. The audience is agog, waiting for the next drop of vitriol to fall from Clune's lips. And fall they do, some viciously funny . . . some vicious ('If Martin Amis had stuck to writing about smoking, shagging and snooker he might have been the next Nick Hornby'). . . ."
bullet "Out of the Rubble." The Guardian, 13 October 2001. In the course of her attack on writers' responses to September 11, Burchill had this to say about Amis: "Martin Amis wrote a particularly self-important piece, and I couldn't help remembering his recent remark about why he'd rather live in Bush's America than Blair's Britain; because "The Writer" needs "an environment of turmoil and injustice rather than one of bland consensus in order to be the best he can be." Well, New York has certainly experienced a good deal of turmoil and injustice now, and one hopes it has had a beneficial effect on Little Marty's wordpower, if nothing else."
bullet To plumb the depths of animus Martin Amis can inspire, consider these excerpts from Julie Burchill's May 2000 attack in The Spectator [To read Burchill's 18 June 2000 letter to the London Times patting herself on the back for her attack, click here; to read the article about Marian Partington's comments on Experience that made Burchill's day, click here; to read ex-husband Tony Parson's recollections of Burchill ("a cruel, stupid coward. A very low form of life"), click here; to read more on the Parsons-Burchill feud, click here]. 

"MAKING A NAME FOR ONESELF" 

It might be fair to say that the foremost practitioners of the English literary novel spent the 1980s denouncing the bitch-goddess Thatcher and all her works - superficiality, selfishness, sucking up to America - and the 1990s rather excitably putting them into practice. Martin Amis, for one, had his distinctly English teeth fixed at great expense after dumping not just his lifelong agent but his wife and the mother of his two sons in order to run off with her younger, prettier, richer, more American close friend; as his sales get smaller, his advances get larger, aided by a new American agent reassuringly known as ‘the Jackal’. As Amis spent the first 20 years of his career railing against greed, emotional incontinence, the tyranny of beauty and America (The Moronic Inferno) in general, this lot came as something of a surprise, to say the least. 

But Martin’s plans to move into the belly of the beast have been somewhat scuppered by his old chum Salman Rushdie, who was recently revealed to have left his (third) wife of two years (who married him while the fatwa was still in place, at considerable risk to herself) and infant son in order to move to the USA to be near his latest flame, a beautiful young model who also writes books on the side - diet books, that is. Lesser luminaries, such as Ian McEwan and Christopher Hitchens, have been involved in vicious divorce cases, invariably centring on Alpha Male’s propensity to trade in old models for new. What was it Muriel Spark said in The Girls of Slender Means? ‘Literary men, if they like women at all, do not want literary women but girls.’ 

Of course, there’s no law against liking a nice bit of T&A, even if you did learn Russian just to read Dostoevsky in the original. Indeed, some might say that such a reward is only deserved. Nevertheless, there is nothing like running off with a girl young enough to be your first wife’s daughter for finally shifting the public’s perception of you from enfant terrible to dirty old man. With the last generation of Brit Lit Lads well, if not too wisely, grown up, critics have been casting about for the next batch, and would appear to have found them in the writers of what is called Bloke Lit and which has turned out to be a massive commercial proposition, shifting units by the million and keeping Martin, Salman et al very far indeed from the top of the bestseller lists. Redbrick though not redneck, they write in an accessible, downbeat style about cars, girls and football, with the occasional dash of violence and distant fathers. 

The male answer to Bridget Jones, Bloke Lit has been credited with bringing novels to the type of man who previously wouldn’t have been seen dead with anything more wordy than Playboy - and who worried that that might look a bit poncy, actually. . . . 

Who can blame little ‘Marty’ (the American nickname he chose for himself in boyhood; there is something uniquely pathetic about people who choose their own nicknames, like the graceless Jew in Heller’s Good as Gold who tries to persuade his friends to call him ‘Skip’) Amis, then, for remaking himself in the image of the Bloke Litters? Difficulties with girls, problem skin, fights with other blokes, distant fathers, life measured out in joints and snooker frames - it’s all here. And oh, oh, oh, you wish it wasn’t. This book reminds me of what my dear departed mother used to say about her cystitis: ‘Ooo - it b’ain’t ’alf lovely when it stops!’ 

According to Mart, he’s only written this book in order to ‘set the record straight’ against the foul accusations of the no-necked press. . . . The fact is that those who seek to ‘set the record straight’ are usually liars, just as those who advertise themselves as ‘honest brokers’ are invariably crooks. I am not saying that Amis is a liar, but he is certainly an incorrigible drama queen, and they usually don’t know they’re doing it. . . . 

Despite Amis’s many protestations of seriousness, there are a whole bunch of photographs of him looking ‘cute’ in this book which I found particularly vile. This isn’t what serious writers do, it’s what film actors do, and apart from proving that Amis was a moderately pretty boy when he was young (in a bum-chum sort of way), I can’t think what the justification is. It is, as Lord Charteris said of Sarah Ferguson, ‘vulgar, vulgar, vulgar’ and so transparently self-serving as to be almost suicidal. One picture is of himself and his brother bathing in an outdoor sink ‘when we were poor’; another caption informs us that ‘Philip was much taller than me’. Well, that’s not really news, is it? Common wisdom has it that at least four of the Seven Dwarves were taller than Mart. 

Being short, shagging, smoking fags - far more people know Amis for these things than have read his novels, and perhaps this is appropriate, despite his wails of anguish, for he is obviously much better at these things than at writing novels. Only last week on holiday I was reading both I Like It Here and The Old Devils, and the freshness and humanity of Amis Senior’s books still have the power to make one gasp as though swiftly sexually penetrated. Then I remembered back to my miserable experiences with Junior’s novels in the Eighties, when you had to read them; what a clogged-up, clod-hopping, plate-juggling great show-off he is, and what a relief it is not to have to read his books any more in case you get laughed at down the Soho Brasserie. (To judge by the sales of The Information, I am not alone in my relief.) In his heart of hearts I can’t believe he doesn’t know how downright weak his fiction is, which may explain the venom with which he here attacks the massively talented young novelist James Buchan, who had the nerve to criticise one of his rotten books in The Spectator once. 

All is cringe-worthy, but I think the section about his cousin, Lucy Partington, who was murdered by Frederick West, sits particularly queasily considering Amis’s own female creations and the huge number of sluts, sexual masochists and characterless lingerie models among them. It was Amis, let us not forget, who invented the concept of the Murderee, in London Fields - Nicola Six, who engineers her own murder for sexual thrills. A Frederick West dream girl, in fact. And in the tragedy of Lucy Partington’s death and Amis’s clumsy attempt to co-opt it as part of a Writer’s Own Story, we see the great flaw that runs through all of his work and ends up here naked and unadorned; namely that a lightweight mind attempting to grapple with heavyweight matters is one of the most wretched spectacles metropolitan life has to offer. If only he’d stuck to writing about smoking, shagging and snooker, on the other hand, he might even have been the next Nick Hornby.

 



This site is featured in
BBC.gif (1270 bytes)
BBC Education Web Guide

Home

 

frontpag.gif (9866 bytes)

 

ie1.gif (14871 bytes)

 

Site maintained by James Diedrick, author of Understanding Martin Amis, 2nd edition (2004).
 All contents © 2004.
Last updated 10 December, 2004. Please read the Disclaimer

 

 

Home | Discussion Board  | Disclaimer Understanding Martin Amis  | James Diedrick  | Albion College